"Pulling a Payne" refers to an astounding golf shot as a reference to Payne Stewart, the professional golfer.
This is often followed up by a series of odd or distasteful dancing in an effort to mock or otherwise humiliate the defeated person or persons.
This can often be accompanied with continued mocking of the person's values, beliefs, or past actions.
This is then followed with the distribution of ridiculous and often inexplicable nicknames
"Dude, I think he just sunk a hole in one, what a Payne!"
"Did he just do the Cha Cha Slide and then defecate on my shoes?!?"
"SEAN YOUNG FUCKED
A HORSE AND TRIED TO PICK UP TWELVE YEAR OLDS"
"Yarglefet, fatatata, text-methage, palmeranian"