Butch lesbian who prefers fisting as her choice of giving sexual pleasure. In the same way as coloured hankies denote what gay men prefer, a huge fuck-off Bon Jovi mullet marks a Butch down as a cuntpuncher.
A person who tells a joke that they think is funny, but actually is not funny. In essence, they have missed the mark and metaphorically "punched the coat" instead.
Coat Puncher has been popularized by the dot-com website bearing the same name.
The sheriff had seenenough, and started to smack the cowpuncher around and ask him how he liked it. What kind of a coward beats the shit out of livestock?
Yea that guy went and jumped the fence and got in there and started slugging the cows, trying to get them to tip over. I think he was one of them cowpunchers.