When a friend asks you to make-out with someone for their birthday.
The person is usually very cute (which makes it a challenge) or not that attractive but nice so they deserve some action.
Claire: "Molly, will you birthday tally Kevin K. for my birthday?"
Molly: "Of course, it might be a bit hard tho cuz he's such a babe and not a manwhore."

by Risque Munsell 7 girls November 4, 2007
Get the birthday tally mug.