Personality Crush 

When you have a crush on someone because of his or her personality and not their looks. This often leads to conflict because you want to be in a relationship with the person; even though, you're not physically attracted to him or her.

"Oh, Jenna is so ugly."
"I know; but, she's so cool. I have a huge personality crush on her.

Personality Crush by Carla Gardner May 3, 2008

Personality Crush 

When you like someone for their personality, but are not otherwise attracted to them.

I've got a huge Personality Crush on Dave!!

Personality Crush by DianaP May 26, 2008