Derived from the name of Broadway Diva Orfeh. Orfail means a fail but is a theatre nerds way of saying it.
Much like the term Patti LuPwn'd

(See "Fail" for further definition)
Kid: Ugh that was such a fail
Theatre Kid: Dontcha mean that was an Orfail
Kid: wtf is an Orfail?
Get the Orfail mug.