a college game, often played in fraternaties, where many mles stand around in a circle masturbating. Whenever someone cum's, they giz on to the cookie that is placed in the middle of the circle. the last person to get off on to the cookie is forced to eat it by his "buddies"
The idiot agreed to join in on a game of mushy cookie without knowing what it is. Schmuck.
by Balzac November 30, 2003
Get the Mushy Cookie mug.
A homo-erotic game played by a group of males circle jerking onto a cookie. The object of the game is to cum/ejaculate the fastest or first. As the group cums/ejaculates onto the cookie the last person in the group to cum/ejaculate then has to eat the cum coverd cookie.

BON APATITE'!!!

Yah I know pretty fuckin disgusting right ...

Well hey don't get mad at me, your the 1 who played the game and then told me about it.
Billy - Hey you guys wanna play mushie cookie?
Group of boys - Yahhh!!!!

Billy - Ok Brian go grab the Oreo's

....7 mins later....

Some bodies sons got a mouth full of CUM!!!

GOT MILK???
by G-white November 25, 2009
Get the Mushie Cookie mug.
The physiologic response in females of sexual arousal (see also <b> wet pussy<b/>.
The first time I kissed him, he got my <b> cookie mushy <b/>
by numnum July 11, 2004
Get the mushy cookie mug.