Theory of Constructed Evidence

The recognition that evidence is never neutral; it is always interpreted through a lens. A strand of hair is just a biological filament until a detective's theory of the crime constructs it as "evidence of the suspect's presence." A statistical correlation is just a number until an economist's model constructs it as "evidence for market manipulation." The theory comes first and dictates what counts as evidence and what that evidence means.

Example: "In the conspiracy forum, the same government press release was constructed as 'evidence of a cover-up' (because they'd admit that if it were true?) and as 'evidence of their brazen transparency' (to throw us off!). The Theory of Constructed Evidence shows the evidence itself was passive; the opposing theories did all the work."

by Dumu The Void January 30, 2026

Meta-Evidence

Evidence about the quality, validity, or interpretation of other evidence. It's the evidence you use to weigh evidence. This includes a study's methodology, the chain of custody for a forensic sample, the calibration records of a sensor, or the historical accuracy of a witness. In a courtroom, the DNA match is evidence; the lab's accreditation and error rate is the meta-evidence. It's the critical layer that separates raw data from a credible claim, and it's where most conspiracy theories and legitimate skepticism violently collide.

Example: "The photo was evidence of the event. The meta-evidence—the JPEG's EXIF data showing it was created two days prior, and the shadow angles being physically impossible—was what proved it was a fake. The evidence lied; the meta-evidence told the truth about the lie."

by Dumu The Void January 30, 2026