bagle eating jew 

A person of Jewish ethnicity who does not actively practice Judaism.

Did you see him at synagogue last week?

No. He's a bagle eating jew.

bagle eating jew by Deanthejew February 4, 2016

bagel eating jew 

A person of Jewish ethnicity who does not actively practice Judaism

Guy 1 I practice Judaism all the time
Guy 2 I'm a bagel eating jew

bagel eating jew by Jarwell September 17, 2016