sheriff star 

Is what you call an asshole which has had anal bleaching, hence it is a 'shiny sheriff star'.

I had a brown butt hole so I got it bleached and now I have a shiny sheriff star! My boyfriend loves it.

She was so fine I polished her sheriff star.

sheriff star by Pradeep July 30, 2006

rusty sheriff star

A brown asshole or poop shoot.

My old lady has a clean rusty sheriff star for a culo.

rusty sheriff star by d0c March 17, 2008

Sheriff's Star 

Another term for one's asshole

Getting ready to give Adam a good long rimjob, Steven quickly discovered Adam's sheriff's star was still dirty from his last dump. Steve then told Adam to take a hot shower and scrub hard

Sheriff's Star by pepperpiper March 3, 2016