Definitions by listserve

Scary Gay 

When a straight guy makes a comment that is supremely gay and causes you to say jeez that is "scary gay"

"I'll suck all your dicks I don't care"

"Wow thats scary gay"

Or

At least he didn't cum on your back like he did to a friend in high school as a joke... That is just Scary Gay

Scary Gay by listserve July 13, 2012