Top definition
A game between two people with penises. Each person covers their penis in peanut butter. Using their respective mouths, they must clean their opponent's penis of peanut butter. The first person to fully clean their opponent's penis is the winner.
"Dan ejaculated in my mouth during our game of peanutbutter-popsicle. Do you think he might be gay?"
by DanielleBananielle April 23, 2018
Get the mug
Get a peanutbutter-popsicle mug for your sister-in-law Sarah.