A fallacy where someone invokes "science" as an authority to settle a question without specifying which science, what evidence, or how it applies. "Science says..." becomes a magic incantation that ends debate. The appeal is fallacious when it treats science as a monolithic oracle rather than a diverse, contested, evolving set of practices and findings. Science doesn't "say" anything—scientists publish studies, which are interpreted, debated, and sometimes overturned. Appeal to Science is the intellectual's version of "because I said so"—using the prestige of science to avoid the work of argument.
Appeal to Science "I questioned a popular health claim. Response: 'Science says it's true!' Which science? Which studies? Published where? Replicated when? 'Science says' is not an argument—it's a conversation-stopper dressed in a lab coat. Appeal to Science: when you want the authority of science without the responsibility of citing it."
by Dumu The Void February 28, 2026
Get the Appeal to Science mug.