Rational Dogmatism
The uncritical, unquestioning acceptance of a particular set of rational principles, often absorbed from one’s education or subculture, without openness to alternative ways of thinking. The rational dogmatist treats their own rationality as simply “clear thinking” and dismisses other frameworks as obviously inferior. They rarely examine their own assumptions about what counts as a “good reason” and react defensively when those assumptions are questioned.
Example: “She claimed she was ‘just being rational’ but couldn’t articulate why her premises were better than his—rational dogmatism, mistaking habit for objectivity.”
Rational Orthodoxy
The dominant, institutionalized set of rational norms and practices within academia, policy, and business, enforced through education, professional standards, and media discourse. Rational orthodoxy privileges analytical, quantitative, cost‑benefit reasoning, treats emotional or intuitive knowledge as suspect, and often marginalizes alternative rationalities (e.g., care ethics, indigenous rationality). It determines what counts as a “sound decision” in many contexts and who gets to be called “reasonable.” It can become a tool for excluding those who think differently.
Example: “The committee rejected community‑based proposals as ‘not rational’ because they lacked formal cost‑benefit analysis—rational orthodoxy, using one model of reason to exclude others.”
Rational Orthodoxy
The dominant, institutionalized set of rational norms and practices within academia, policy, and business, enforced through education, professional standards, and media discourse. Rational orthodoxy privileges analytical, quantitative, cost‑benefit reasoning, treats emotional or intuitive knowledge as suspect, and often marginalizes alternative rationalities (e.g., care ethics, indigenous rationality). It determines what counts as a “sound decision” in many contexts and who gets to be called “reasonable.” It can become a tool for excluding those who think differently.
Example: “The committee rejected community‑based proposals as ‘not rational’ because they lacked formal cost‑benefit analysis—rational orthodoxy, using one model of reason to exclude others.”
Rational Dogmatism by Dumu The Void April 18, 2026
Get the Rational Dogmatism mug.