A popular gay. Usually seen in, or from, upstate New York. These gays fit in well with straight high school/college jocks. They’re often seen on Snapchat cuddling or in close proximity to conventionally straight men.
John: Hey man. Who was that guy in your bed last night??

Nick: oh, that’s just Andrew. He’s from New York.

John: ohhh I didn’t know you were gay.

Nick: ME? GAY? Nahhh... Andrew is a New York Gay. Ya know?
John: OHHH that makes more sense.
by Johnny cobb February 19, 2019
Get the New York Gay mug.