toffee butter 

when you theres feces in anal canal and you push it up. and when you ejaculate inside the canal the 'toffee butter' comes out

I toffee buttered her so good last night!

toffee butter by vinvandope November 27, 2017

Butter Toffee 

When you are having buttsex, cum in her butt, pull out, then proceed to fall asleep before cleaning up. In the morning, she sucks the cum-crusty doodoo butter off your dick and it gets stuck in her teeth like toffee always does. That cum-crusty doodoo butter is butter toffee.

Yo... I had some butter toffee this morning and I cannot get it out of my teeth. I tried brushing and everything.

Butter Toffee by ImFCKD January 28, 2017