by Fredz November 1, 2006
When you place a wad of toilet paper in the empty bowl before you take a shit. This "pillow" muffles the sound...so no one knows you're shitting.
Friend: I'm going out of town this weekend with Mike for the first time and staying in a hotel. How will I poop without him knowing?
Me: Dude, just make a shit pillow.
Me: Dude, just make a shit pillow.
by quickpause February 2, 2015
A shit pillow is when you shit in someone’s pillow case and wait for them to lay their head on it, it’s pretty evil
by Shaquavion Taneta O’Quayle Jr. February 1, 2023