When wiping your ass, the finger goes through the toilet paper or the paper misses the shit in your ass completely & you get shit under your nail.
The toilet paper failed & JOHNNY CAME OUT WITH NAIL FUDGE!

Also the new CARVEL CAKE "FUDGIE THE NAIL"
by 1Adam12 September 26, 2007
Get the Nail Fudge mug.
were one dips finger nail or tonail in shit and eats it
Nail Fudge
by Calern7 April 23, 2023
Get the Nail Fudge mug.