The look of horrified surprise caused by being poked from behind by a phallic object, most often the penis of an Indian.
Right as the picture was taken, a smiling Kumar brandished his penis and poked Megan in the back. Although she could barely feel it, she still experienced an Indian Surprise that she will not soon forget!
by a3 October 4, 2007
While having sex doggy style, the male slips his penis into the female's anal cavity. As she lets out a surprised scream, the male reaches around and cups her mouth with his hand so her scream sounds like that of an Indian.
by mdcone January 30, 2018