When one person puts sticks of butter in their shoe, cooks it in the microwave, and fucks it aggressively while the butter is hot.
Carl: I got bored last night, so I tried doing a Hot Butter Shoe.
Jeff: How was it?
Carl: My dick's a little burnt, but otherwise it was fun.
Jeff: How was it?
Carl: My dick's a little burnt, but otherwise it was fun.
by ButteryManbabys April 16, 2019