1. The sloppiest, saltiest, most savory dome known to man.
2. A beegizzle
"The Ice cream man fell to his knees when I demanded a Butter Popsicle "

"Yo dude, Courtney just gave me the craziest Butter Popsicle I have ever been given under the summer sun."
by Thegreatblumpkin6969 May 20, 2016
Get the Butter Popsicle mug.
A noun or sometimes action that refers to fucking a girl in the ass so hard that when you pull your dick out it is covered in shit and blood making it look very similar to peanut butter and jelly. The girl the precedes to suck the shit and blood covered dick like a popsicle.
Dude I totally gave my girl that good Peanut Butter Jelly Popsicle last night!
by Bussy Benis December 27, 2019
Get the Peanut Butter Jelly Popsicle mug.