When someone butt clugs a few too couple of drinks, and it needs to come out. A friend takes a plunger and and tries to pump out the liquid for your ass.
“Oh Damn Kelly. I drank too much! Would you mind Anal Plunger - ing my ass!! Thanks girl. BFFS for life.”
You have sex with an asshole. And it is good. After having said sex, the asshole has been stretched to such proportions that you can put some kind of small trinket inside for the next person to find. It's a surprise!!!
Upon inserting my penis, I found an oddly shaped d20. I wondered how it had gotten there, and then remembered her last boyfriend had been into anal plundering. I continued to fuck her, not testing my luck.
When someone gives rough, vigorous anal sex, creating a vicous bleeding wound out of the sphincter. Then pulls out with blinding speed erecting a pink sock of unimaginable size.
Jane calls me an Anal Plunderer because I tore out her anus and sent her to the hospital in unbearable pain, while she beld from her anal oraphus.
Ruler of Lake Titicaca. Rumored to have a bunghole that gets very angry if it does not receive toilet paper. Cornholio the Great is often seen walking around with his shirt over his head and his hands in the air, chanting songs about his power, and his bunghole.
"I am Cornholio! You do not want to face the wrath of my bunghole, for I need TP!"
Butthead: Shut up, Beavis! (uh huh huh huh)
Beavis: Um, okay. (heh heh heh heh).