It's when you wipe your ass from back to front while brushing the shit filled toilet paper against your nut sack. This will leave a decent amount of feces on your sack and in your ball hair. You then proceed to find a nasty whore that doesn't mind having a shit smeared ball sack dunked in her filthy mouth. "hence a nutter butter tea bag".
Shit on ball sack, dunked in a mouth. "Nutter butter tea bag"
by Peanut butter bar February 22, 2014
Get the nutter butter tea bag mug.
A person who's cum is very thick and heavy
Girl 1: Did you spit or swallow last night?

Girl 2: I spit, he was a peanut butter nutter!

Girl 1: OMG! Hahaha
by Mdad February 12, 2016
Get the Peanut Butter Nutter mug.
The sex act of tying to butter faced girls together and Cumming on them
2 butter faced girls let me make Nutter butter bars
by Cretioon September 2, 2021
Get the Nutter butter bars mug.
Th act of fucking girl in her pussy until you're about to explode your load. You then pull out and stick it in her ass and blow your load. Nutter buttering.
I had this freaky girl that had me nutter buttering her
by The name is Jefe October 6, 2019
Get the nutter buttering mug.
A man who never uses a condom and uses women as a semen dispenser.
That kid Aaron is a nutter butter, be careful you might get pregnant from him.
by angsiga21 March 31, 2019
Get the Nutter Butter mug.