1 definition by eyeman69

Where you put your dick in a freshly-baked Apple pie like what Jim levenstein did in the 1999 film American Pie.
Matt: "Did you hear what happened to Steve?"

Rob: "No."

Matt: "He did the American Pie Challenge and got hospitalized because of the third-degree burns on his dick."

Rob: "Damn."
by eyeman69 August 28, 2022
Get the American Pie challenge mug.