1 definition by Netlion15
A sexual move in which a male partner leaves a freshly made Papa Johns Pizza out to rot for 2 to 3 months, and then shoves it up his female partner's vagina.
Leo: Taylor smells like rotten cheese and tomatoes today.
Don: Yea. Kyle gave her a Rusty Papa John last night
Don: Yea. Kyle gave her a Rusty Papa John last night
by Netlion15 December 18, 2010