1 definition by 4horsemen

A crying whale eye is what females or homosexuals achieve when a man cums in their anus and the semen leaks out.
I thought I pulled out of her in time, but I then I turned to find her cryin' whale eye looking right at me.

or

Don't be such a fucking cryin' whale eye.
by 4horsemen October 2, 2007
Get the cryin' whale eye mug.