Top definition
Where a girl who from every rational viewpoint should be super hot, but for some indescribable reason is ugly.

Sometimes not immediately obvious.
"Sarah Michelle Gellar ranks 10 out of 10 on the buffy face scale."

"Check out Ashley, is she hot or what?
DUDE, no way, she's got total buffy face!
--oh. Woah. I never noticed! Ew."
by SunnydaleSam July 28, 2010
Get the mug
Get a buffy face mug for your guy Manley.