The best pizza in Wheeling, WV. Thick crust, square slices, pepperoni to die for, and the cheese just melts in your mouth. I've eaten it all my life and it is amazing. There are several locations within a 20 mile radius of Wheeling, but the one with the best taste is the original location, in Elm Grove (one of the largest neighborhoods in Wheeling).
Man #1 (from Moundsville): Hey dude, wanna run out to Glendale to grab some DiCarlo's Pizza?
Man #2: Glendale's pizza is shit. Let's grab some from Elm Grove.
Man #1: Is it worth the 25 minute drive?
Man #2: Hellz yeah!
Man #2: Glendale's pizza is shit. Let's grab some from Elm Grove.
Man #1: Is it worth the 25 minute drive?
Man #2: Hellz yeah!
by xbrad222x July 2, 2009