Definitions by Bobby Malone

peanut butter suprise 

spread peanut butter on your dick and then fuck a girl in the ass; after ejaculation, force the girl to suck everything off the cock.
(optional) lick the Peanut Butter out of the girls ass.

Samantha wanted a snack so I gave her a Peanut Butter Suprise (PBS).

peanut butter suprise by Bobby Malone October 30, 2007