Skip to main content

Cincinnati Surprise 

When you shit in a pillow case and beat someone about the head and shoulders.
He didn't pay for his half of the hotel so he got a cincinnati surprise.

Cincinatti Surprise 

When you take a shit in a pillow case and beat someone over the head with it several times.
Billy was bein' an ass so i gave him the ol' Cincinnati Surprise!
Cincinatti Surprise by Pater June 26, 2003