look up any word, like sex:
 
1.
When you are having sex with a girl in missionary position and unbenounced to her you are shitting in your cupped hand. Once she had reached climax she is slapped across the face with feces.
I gave my girl last night a pudding surprise, and now she won't talk to me.
by Blade707 February 04, 2011
 
2.
When you are banging your hoe in the butt and she flarts. Giving your man stick a nice coat of ass juice.
Friend "What did you with that hoe i saw you with last night"

You "That hoe gave me a Pudding Surprise"
by mac5611 August 25, 2009