look up any word, like sex:
When you are having sex with a girl in missionary position and unbenounced to her you are shitting in your cupped hand. Once she had reached climax she is slapped across the face with feces.
I gave my girl last night a pudding surprise, and now she won't talk to me.
by Blade707 February 04, 2011
When you are banging your hoe in the butt and she flarts. Giving your man stick a nice coat of ass juice.
Friend "What did you with that hoe i saw you with last night"

You "That hoe gave me a Pudding Surprise"
by mac5611 August 25, 2009