Top definition
A penis that has the circumference equal to that of a nickel, and is about 5 inches long. Therefore, a nickel pickle is essentially only worth about 5ยข due to its lack of girth and length.
Girl: My boyfriend said he had a huge cock, but it turned out it was only a nickel pickle.
by AutoMatt Ickly April 30, 2014
Get the mug
Get a nickel pickle mug for your cousin Georges.
2
#1 - Wow, that guy is such a nickel pickle.

#2 - Dude, James totally has a nickel pickle.
by sheldon_o December 21, 2018
Get the mug
Get a nickel pickle mug for your boyfriend Georges.