A Ketchup Pie is a normal Cream Pie (Filling a Girl with cum during Sex), except the female is on her period. The female could also have released some of her period sauce at the time of Ketchup Pie
Guy 1: Dude I just cream pied my gf last night!
Guy 2: isn't she on her period?
Guy 1: yeah... Why??
Guy 2: so it was a Ketchup Pie, not a Cream Pie!
Guy 2: isn't she on her period?
Guy 1: yeah... Why??
Guy 2: so it was a Ketchup Pie, not a Cream Pie!
by Saucy Phox November 17, 2020