an in-betweenie belly button; the mixture of an outie (belly button) and an innie (belly hole); belly button + belly hole = belly butthole.
Person 1: “Do you have a belly button, belly hole, or a belly butthole?” Person 2: “Well, I have an in-betweenie... so, a belly butthole!”
by BellyEnthusiast69420 June 20, 2020
A belly butthole is like a belly button only it goes deeper so that when you stick your finger in there and pull it back out it smells funny.
by mcdisease July 24, 2015
by Belly Button Nicole November 30, 2014