A Banana Butter-Cum Pie is a banana-creme pie with a dollop of whipped cum on it.
The other cadets all donated their sperm so we could all have Banana Butter-Cum Pie for dessert.
by USAF Cadet January 31, 2021
Get a Banana Butter-Cum Pie mug for your friend Jovana.
When a group of guys are A) gangbanging B) running a train on a girl. One guy cream pies the girl and another goes down and eats the girl out. Licking out the cum from the other guy.
Dude, remember that chick from the other night? Beau, banana split pied her after Tasi.
by pteredactyll March 20, 2015
Get the banana split pie neck gaiter and mug.