(adj) Possessing qualities relating to being Jewish.
Jenna: Grossman? That sounds bagelly.

Jake: Mr. Hymowitz gave me this cheap ass candy. What a bagelly mofo!
by florida_swag March 13, 2011
Get a bagelly mug for your buddy James.
When you are feeling in the mood for a bagel with a good helping of cream cheese.
"I'm feeling bagelly today."
by crystalizationn March 09, 2009
Get a bagelly mug for your guy Vivek.
That which posesses similar or identical characteristics to that of a bagel.
I could really go for something bagelly.
by DulesIV March 28, 2010
Get a bagelly mug for your fish Vivek.