Top definition
A meme-ish inside joke that you would understand if you watched Andrew Bravener on BlogTV (Dec. 16th,2009). Some dude who called himself Keith pretended to be a moderator and threatened to ban Andrew because he was playing "copyrighted music". AB, annoyed yet mildly amused, responded to the troll with these three simple yet epic words. The phrase is now a Twitter hash tag (#reallykeithreally), and Andrew has made the first "Really, Keith, Really!?" t-shirt.

His fans soon followed suit.

It can also be used in a similar style to FML.
I just failed my chemistry final...Really, Keith, Really!?
by miss hana-hana December 17, 2009
Get the mug
Get a Really, Keith, Really!? mug for your papa Callisto.