The equivalent of Swamp Ass on your balls. In other words, it's when your junk is really sweaty.
Dave: Dude, there is a battle going on.

Tony: What?
Dave: Bro, it's Nutter Butter vs. Swamp Ass over the Taint Dome.
by Trombone73 July 02, 2016
Get a Nutter Butter mug for your boyfriend Georges.
A sexual method, where the male ejaculates in the females anus, in which the female pushes it out along with solid waste. The 'Nutter' means "bust a nut", and 'Butter' is the product of the faeces, and semen mixing together.
person1: "dude, it was so hot, i gave her the hottest Nutter Butter.
person2: " that sounds awesome, what colour was it?"
by Diktugnutz February 15, 2017
Get a Nutter Butter mug for your father Vivek.
Semen build-up that is created in the testicles of a male when he has not ejaculated for an extended period of time. The substance is so thick and creamy, that it has the consistency of peanut butter. The term is derived from the slang term "Busting a nut," and from that lovable food item: peanut butter.
"Oh David, you just made NUTTER BUTTER on my stomach.... Where's the bread!?"
by Rusty-Spoon January 10, 2010
Get the Nutter Butter neck gaiter and mug.
The process of sticking peanut butter on your dick and inside a girl's asshole, fucking her in the ass. After you cum, you eat all of the peanut butter out of her asshole.

(Also referred to as P.B. & A)
Did you hear Roger likes to nutter butter on Swilly?
by Tyler Jean January 21, 2011
Get a Nutter Butter mug for your Uncle Manley.
When a guy nuts in a jar of peanut butter, while lying in a bathtub.
"When we asked if he really fucked a jar of peanut butter, he replied 'Yes, I bought it myself.'"
"Wow, he actually did a full-on nutter butter."
by UwU, not OwO June 27, 2020
Get a Nutter Butter mug for your mate Manley.
When you ejaculate in between the ass cheeks of a person, and push the cheeks together, thus creating a human Nutter Butter.
“Yo I pulled a Nutter Butter on Jeremy’s mom last night. Shit was delicious my guy.”
by thesploogiestsplooger October 18, 2018
Get a Nutter Butter mug for your cat José.
The nutter butter is a delicious, kinky, and nutritious sexual act given by a woman to a man. The nutter butter happens when a man spreads peanut butter on his 'junk' and then proceeds to place it into his partners' mouth. He then MUST nut (a.k.a. skeet, jizz, cum, and the like) into her mouth. Hence, the nutter butter.
I gave that slut last night a nutter butter. The peanut butter from my dick, was sticking to the roof of her mouth, so I washed off with mah jizz.

Woman: "Peanut butter is my favorite! =D"
Man: "Then you would love a nutter butter!"
by Rezaerection July 03, 2010
Get a Nutter Butter mug for your fish Jovana.