A gay man who is afraid of anal, because of the pain that will accompany it.
I want my boyfriend so badly, but I'm just too damn butt shy to let him anal me
by GayBootyButtCheeks October 3, 2012
Get the Butt Shy mug.
The inability to take a shit with anyone else in the house.
Terri has shy butt when her husband is home.
by shyhole November 17, 2008
Get the Shy Butt mug.