Top definition
When engaging in intercourse with a girl that ejaculates so thick that it looks like you are churning butter in her vagina.
I turned the lights on after fucking this chick the other day. She left so much butter on my cock she had to be an Amish Girl
by twistedATbangedupNET February 08, 2010
Get the mug
Get a Amish Girl mug for your friend José.