An elevator list is a list of all of the people that you're allowed to have sex with if your ever stuck in an elevator with them.
LUCAS: Isn’t it ‘Five Minutes in the Closet’?
BROOKE: Yeah, if you’re in junior high. But the great part about this is; you know how everybody has their elevator list?
BROOKE: Your elevator list! Come on! The list of people you’re allowed to have sex with if you’re ever stuck in an elevator with them.
SKILLS: Halle Berry.
PEYTON: Jack Black.
MOUTH: Brooke Davis.
BROOKE: Well! Everybody makes a list and if two people have each others names…five minutes in the elevator