A girl who is hot but her shoes (butter shoes).
Like 'butter face'.
Origins from the footlocker back to school ad
*Hot girl walks in wearing crocs*
Guy 1: Oh oh oh..look at her
Guy 2: Man she is super fine!
Guy 1: Wait no shes not, shes a butter shoes
Guy 2: Waht!?
Guy 1: Everything is hot but her shoes,
I mean look at those..Im depressed right now
Guy 2: Dude im gonna be sick!
*Average girl walks in wearing nikes*
Guy 1: Oh wait a minute..Im happy again
<adj> When describing a female, everything about her is appealing except for her shoes
(hot girl walks in)
Guy A: Oh oh oh! Her, mmm shes super fine...
Guy B: No shes not, shes a buttershoes
Guy A: A what?
Guy B: A buttershoes, everthing about her is hot 'but her shoes'
Guy A: oh oh...
Guy B: I'm depressed from now
Guy A: I think I'm gonna be sick..
Everything is attractive about the girl... except the shoes
Guy 1: She's hot!
Guy 2: No, she's a buttershoes.
Guy 1: A what?
Guy 2: Buttershoes. Everything is hot, but her shoes.