When you ejaculate inside of a girl during anal sex. She then proceeds to push out your man juice like she normally would in a regular vaginal cream pie but it comes out of her ass instead.
Dude I came inside of her ass last night! She totally fudge pied me when I was done! It was so tits!
by Moshbearpig May 18, 2013
A pie with a 'fudge' (Title text: shit) filling
Will Gordon Brown be eating fudge pie today after his recent parliamentary defeat?
by Fredster C June 13, 2008