Kanye West: Yeah.
Cartman: You're a gay fish.
Kanye West: What?! Why e'rybody startin' des rumors 'bout me?! I ain't no gay fish!
Guy 2: Yeah!
Guy 1: So, you like to put them in your mouth and chew on them?
Guy 2: Of course!
Guy 1: ..So, you're a gay fish?
Guy 2: ....
comparable to "icup". Although the creator is unknown, there is rumor that the joke itself was made by Carlos Mencia. This setup is as follows:
"Hey, do you like fishsticks?"
"Do you like to put fishsticks in your mouth?"
"Then You're a gayfish"
Up to date the only person who doesn't get the joke is Kanye West.
Victim: "Yeah, I love fishsticks"
Joker: "Do you like to put fishsticks into your mouth?"
Joker: "Then you're a Gayfish."
Me: Do you like putting fishsticks in your mouth?
Me: Then you're a gay fish.
Cartman: "Love 'em!"
Jimmy: "So you like to put fishsticks in your mouth?"
Cartman: "Yes, I like to fish dicks in my mouth"
Jimmy: "So you're a gay fish?"